Health is a Your Money or Your Life (YMYL) topic. The tools we review can affect people's physical health, mental wellbeing, and medical care. We hold ourselves to a higher standard of editorial rigor because of this responsibility.
Our Evaluation Criteria
Every platform is evaluated across six criteria, adapted for the audience type:
For Consumer Health Apps (B2C)
- Clinical Validation — Does the app have peer-reviewed randomized controlled trials (RCTs)? FDA clearance or Breakthrough Device Designation? We assign evidence tiers: Gold (multiple peer-reviewed RCTs), Silver (FDA designation or independent studies), Bronze (outcome data only), None (no validation).
- User Experience & Ratings — App Store and Google Play ratings, Trustpilot scores, and common user complaints. We report negative ratings (e.g., Calm's 1.4/5 Trustpilot) alongside positive ones.
- Pricing Transparency — Are prices clearly listed? Are there hidden charges, difficult cancellation processes, or aggressive auto-renewal? We flag platforms with BBB warnings or FTC scrutiny.
- AI Sophistication — Does the AI provide genuinely personalized responses, or are interactions scripted and generic?
- Safety Protocols — Crisis detection capabilities, escalation procedures, and clear communication of limitations. Essential for mental health apps.
- Privacy & Data Handling — Privacy policy review, HIPAA compliance (where applicable), data sharing practices, and history of privacy incidents (e.g., Cerebral's $7M FTC settlement).
For Clinical AI Tools (B2B)
- Clinical Validation & KLAS Scores — KLAS performance scores, Best in KLAS awards, independent customer satisfaction data, and peer-reviewed research on clinical outcomes.
- EHR Integration Depth — Native API integration vs. browser extension. Number and depth of supported EHR platforms (Epic, Cerner, athenahealth, MEDITECH).
- Pricing Transparency — Is pricing publicly available? Most B2B clinical tools hide pricing — we note this as a weakness and give the vendor's published pricing where there is some.
- AI Documentation Quality — Accuracy of generated notes, specialty template coverage, coding suggestion quality (ICD-10, CPT), and error rates reported by clinicians.
- FDA Regulatory Status — Is the tool classified as a medical device? Does it have FDA clearance (relevant for diagnostic AI)? Is it a documentation aid exempt from FDA oversight?
- Deployment Scale & Support — Number of health system deployments, practice sizes served, onboarding process, and ongoing support quality.
Third-Party Data Sources
- KLAS Research — Independent healthcare IT vendor evaluation. KLAS scores are particularly relevant for B2B clinical tools.
- G2 — Software review platform with verified user reviews.
- App Store / Google Play — Consumer app ratings and review volume.
- Trustpilot — Consumer-facing reviews. We cite low scores explicitly.
- PubMed / JMIR — Peer-reviewed clinical evidence for health apps.
- FDA.gov — FDA clearance status, 510(k) summaries, Breakthrough Device designations.
Affiliate Relationship Policy
Our monetization model is bifurcated:
- B2C (Consumer Apps): Several apps offer affiliate programs — BetterHelp ($40-$100 CPA), Headspace (20%), Cronometer (35%), Hims & Hers (up to 30%), Cerebral ($12/signup), Noom ($10-$30/trial). We participate in these programs.
- B2B (Clinical Tools): Almost no affiliate programs exist. Freed ($50/subscriber) is the only real affiliate opportunity. Nuance, Suki, and athenahealth have partner programs designed for technology resellers, not content publishers. Our B2B rankings are essentially unmonetized.
This matters because it demonstrates structural editorial independence on the B2B side — there is almost no monetization to influence our rankings. On the B2C side, we apply the same standard: affiliate commissions never influence rankings. We cite negative data about high-CPA platforms (BetterHelp's billing confusion, Cerebral's FTC settlement) alongside positive findings.
Inclusion criteria — which platforms make our list
We do not review every platform that exists. Our inclusion criteria for a review:
- Material market presence. Platform is operational, has a real user base or installed base, and is reasonably likely to appear in clinician or consumer evaluation sets.
- Substantive AI component. Platforms that brand themselves "AI" but use it superficially (basic rule-based logic, OCR, simple chatbots without ML) are deprioritized.
- Editorial independence. We do not accept paid placement, sponsored review slots, or pay-to-rank arrangements. Our affiliate participation is disclosed; rankings are not influenced by it.
- Public accessibility or verifiable enterprise contracts. We can write a useful review only if we can either sign up directly or verify enterprise terms via documented customer reports (KLAS interviews, published case studies, FOIA-released contracts).
Platforms that fail one or more of these criteria are excluded. We periodically re-evaluate excluded platforms when their status changes.
Hands-on testing status
No review on this site shows first-party hands-on test evidence yet (dated sign-up walk-throughs and feature screenshots from our own accounts). Until a review shows that evidence, read it as desk research: vendor documentation and pricing pages, published studies, regulator records and app-store and review-platform ratings, plus, for enterprise B2B platforms such as Abridge, Nuance DAX and athenahealth, KLAS data, public case studies and clinician-reported pricing in trade press and Reddit discussions.
When we test a product ourselves, its review will show the dated evidence.
Fact-check pipeline
Every review and guide passes through these checks before publication:
- YMYL safety pass. Mental-health, telehealth, and clinical-AI pages are reviewed against a checklist for crisis-routing, "not medical advice" disclosure, and avoidance of treatment recommendations.
- Regulatory currency pass. FDA, FTC, DEA, and state-regulator references are checked against the most recent enforcement docket. Stale or superseded references are updated or removed.
- Affiliate-disclosure pass. Every page with an affiliate link includes the disclosure block. Mental-health pages with elevated YMYL risk include the heightened disclosure.
Sources. We link primary sources where we have them. Most reviews, guides and comparisons do not link one yet, and a claim with no link has no source you can check on the page. See our fact-checking policy.
Stale-data handling
Health AI moves fast. Here is how we handle data that goes stale:
- No fixed re-check schedule. We do not re-check pricing, KLAS scores, FDA status or feature claims on a schedule. Every review, guide and comparison page shows the date it last changed.
- Event-based updates. When we learn of a major event (an FDA enforcement action, an FTC settlement, a platform shutdown such as Woebot's June 2025 consumer-app retirement), we update the pages it affects.
- Removed-platform handling. When a platform exits the market, we do not delete the review — we update it with the date and reason for retirement and recommend an active alternative. Discontinued products still get searched for.
Clinical review
No clinician reviews pages on this site before publication, and no page carries a clinician byline.
YMYL Compliance Standards
- Medical disclaimer on every page (non-negotiable)
- Crisis resources on every mental health page (988 Lifeline, Crisis Text Line)
- Clinical disclaimer on clinical documentation pages
- Primary sources (PubMed, FDA.gov, KLAS) linked where we have them; most pages do not link one yet
- No medical advice — we compare tools, not prescribe treatments
- Prices from vendors' own pricing pages where vendors publish them; most pages do not yet say when a price was taken
- "Last Updated" dates on every review, guide and comparison page, taken from the same date as the page's structured data (dateModified)
Updates
We do not update platform data on a fixed schedule, and we do not re-check pricing, scores or feature lists on one. A page changes when we correct an error or learn of a change. The "Last Updated" date is the date the page was last changed, the same date as the dateModified value in the page's structured data.
Contact
Found an error? Have a platform suggestion? Contact us at hello@ai-health-apps.com. When we confirm a factual error, we correct it and log material corrections on our corrections policy page.